Complete with two heavy-duty bank vault doors, safety deposit boxes, framed money bags, and other nods to the past, Milton’s just-opened Two Pence Market transforms an intimidating fortress of a 1929 building into a bright and welcoming space for locals to gather, eat, and connect, all while paying homage to Milton’s industrial past.
Dan Kerrigan, the restaurateur behind Steel & Rye—a five-minute walk down the road—and Prairie Fire in Brookline, has pivoted away from the traditional dining experience for his newest project, an all-day market and community space. The Eliot Street building was a bank from the 1920s until 2023, when developer JD Wild decided to buy the property and worked with Kerrigan to figure out a plan. The duo mulled a restaurant but ultimately landed on a more dynamic concept in hopes of fulfilling a community need.
In 2020, when the pandemic made dining spaces more difficult to access, Kerrigan added a bakery and outdoor picnic tables to Steel & Rye, where he observed families gathering with their friends and pets, enjoying a casual space to talk and relax. That’s what Milton wants, he believes. “[Two Pence Market] is a reaction to paying attention to the community and seeing what is needed,” he says.
Inside Two Pence Market in Milton Village. / Photo by Avary Amaral
Wild—who grew up on Martha’s Vineyard, where each town has its own market with a specific identity—was the one to suggest an all-day market. The goal? An environment where locals could buy fresh produce and meticulously sourced food products but also enjoy meals and drinks indoors and out while reading, chatting, or checking email.
In the design process, Kerrigan and Wild prioritized maintaining the building’s historical integrity, making sure it’d still look like it belonged in Milton Village, full of old, brick factories. “It’s incredibly important to respect what was here,” Kerrigan says. “[The buildings] are not museums; they need to be upgraded and brought into a place where people can comfortably use them today, but just stripping that character away from them and putting inexpensive new building materials on them would be a real bummer.”
To find that sweet spot, the team had to break down a few of the more daunting elements from the property’s bank era, when wrought-iron fencing, for instance, showed the public their life savings were being protected. Now, part of that fence has been removed, allowing a seamless connection from sidewalk to entrance; the remaining fencing is adorned with flower boxes. A large covered terrace has replaced old garden beds overgrown with weeds, with additional uncovered patio seating on the other side of the building. Next to the entrance marked by two gas lanterns, there is still a night depository shoot, which Kerrigan himself used for over ten years after nights at Steel & Rye when the building still operated as a bank.
Two Pence Market, located in a former bank space, features some of the bank’s old items in its décor—and uses a vault as a wine closet. / Photos by Avary Amaral
Inside, more reclaimed bank paraphernalia: Old filing shelves, for instance, now hold fresh produce from local farms, including Ward’s Berry Farm in Sharon. (The market also features a robust collection of dry and refrigerated goods, all selected by Kerrigan and culinary director Brendan Joy.) Ledgers and money bags that the team found in the building decorate a hallway; and one vault, with 14-inch reinforced walls, is now a wine closet.
The historic design is a lot to take in, but customers are here for the food, too: There are bagels (and bagel sandwiches), breads, and more from Steel & Rye’s bakery, plus a seasonal soup, smoothies, café drinks, and a hot bar with build-your-own-bowl accoutrements. Executive chef Alison Hearn also oversees a rotating selection of seasonal prepared foods, like a spicy peanut noodle bowl and fresh pastas with vodka sauce. The kitchen is in the basement, where another gleamingly intricate bank vault door protects the bagel recipe the team has worked on for over a year.
“One of the single most important things to me was that Two Pence Market had its own food identity and was offering a whole variety of foods that felt nothing like Steel & Rye,” says Kerrigan, adding that while the options might be different from his other restaurants, the intentionality is still the same, using produce from local farms and companies like Red Fire Farm, Ground Up Grain, and Browne Trading Co., to bring joy and comfort to the community. Now, locals have the added ability to purchase the goods the culinary team uses in its kitchen and loves so much.